:: Fundamental Analysis ::
What is Fundamental Analysis?
Fundamental analysis is the examination of the underlying forces that affect the well being of the
economy, industry groups, and companies. As with most analysis, the goal is to derive a forecast and
profit from future price movements. At the company level, fundamental analysis may involve
examination of financial data, management, business concept and competition. At the industry level,
there might be an examination of supply and demand forces for the products offered. For the national
economy, fundamental analysis might focus on economic data to assess the present and future growth
of the economy. To forecast future stock prices, fundamental analysis combines economic, industry,
and company analysis to derive a stock's current fair value and forecast future value. If fair value
is not equal to the current stock price, fundamental analysts believe that the stock is either over
or under valued and the market price will ultimately gravitate towards fair value. Fundamentalists
do not heed the advice of the random walkers and believe that markets are weak-form efficient. By
believing that prices do not accurately reflect all available information, fundamental analysts look
to capitalize on perceived price discrepancies.
General Steps to Fundamental Evaluation
Even though there is no one clear-cut method, a breakdown is presented below in the order an investor
might proceed. This method employs a top-down approach that starts with the overall economy and then
works down from industry groups to specific companies. As part of the analysis process, it is important
to remember that all information is relative. Industry groups are compared against other industry groups
and companies against other companies. Usually, companies are compared with others in the same group. For
example, a telecom operator (Verizon) would be compared to another telecom operator (SBC Corp), not to
an oil company (ChevronTexaco).
Economic Forecast
First and foremost in a top-down approach would be an overall evaluation of the general economy. The economy
is like the tide and the various industry groups and individual companies are like boats. When the economy
expands, most industry groups and companies benefit and grow. When the economy declines, most sectors and
companies usually suffer. Many economists link economic expansion and contraction to the level of interest
rates. Interest rates are seen as a leading indicator for the stock market as well. Below is a chart of the
S&P 500 and the yield on the 10-year note over the last 30 years. Although not exact, a correlation between
stock prices and interest rates can be seen. Once a scenario for the overall economy has been developed, an
investor can break down the economy into its various industry groups.
Group Selection
If the prognosis is for an expanding economy, then certain groups are likely to benefit more than
others. An investor can narrow the field to those groups that are best suited to benefit from the
current or future economic environment. If most companies are expected to benefit from an expansion,
then risk in equities would be relatively low and an aggressive growth-oriented strategy might be
advisable. A growth strategy might involve the purchase of technology, biotech, semiconductor and
cyclical stocks. If the economy is forecast to contract, an investor may opt for a more conservative
strategy and seek out stable income-oriented companies. A defensive strategy might involve the
purchase of consumer staples, utilities and energy-related stocks.
To assess a industry group's potential, an investor would want to consider the overall growth rate,
market size, and importance to the economy. While the individual company is still important, its
industry group is likely to exert just as much, or more, influence on the stock price. When stocks
move, they usually move as groups; there are very few lone guns out there. Many times it is more
important to be in the right industry than in the right stock! The chart below shows that relative
performance of 5 sectors over a 7-month time frame. As the chart illustrates, being in the right
sector can make all the difference.
Narrow Within the Group
Once the industry group is chosen, an investor would need to narrow the list of companies before
proceeding to a more detailed analysis. Investors are usually interested in finding the leaders and
the innovators within a group. The first task is to identify the current business and competitive
environment within a group as well as the future trends. How do the companies rank according to market
share, product position and competitive advantage? Who is the current leader and how will changes within
the sector affect the current balance of power? What are the barriers to entry? Success depends on an
edge, be it marketing, technology, market share or innovation. A comparative analysis of the competition
within a sector will help identify those companies with an edge, and those most likely to keep it.
Company Analysis
Business Plan
The business plan, model or concept forms the bedrock upon which all else is built. If the plan,
model or concepts stink, there is little hope for the business. For a new business, the questions
may be these: Does its business make sense? Is it feasible? Is there a market? Can a profit be made?
For an established business, the questions may be: Is the company's direction clearly defined? Is
the company a leader in the market? Can the company maintain leadership?
Management
In order to execute a business plan, a company requires top-quality management. Investors might look at
management to assess their capabilities, strengths and weaknesses. Even the best-laid plans in the most
dynamic industries can go to waste with bad management (AMD in semiconductors). Alternatively, even strong
management can make for extraordinary success in a mature industry (Alcoa in aluminum). Some of the questions
to ask might include: How talented is the management team? Do they have a track record? How long have they
worked together? Can management deliver on its promises? If management is a problem, it is sometimes best to
move on.
Putting it All Together
After all is said and done, an investor will be left with a handful of companies that stand out from the pack.
Over the course of the analysis process, an understanding will develop of which companies stand out as potential
leaders and innovators. In addition, other companies would be considered laggards and unpredictable. The final
step of the fundamental analysis process is to synthesize all data, analysis and understanding into actual
picks.
Strengths of Fundamental Analysis
Long-term Trends
Fundamental analysis is good for long-term investments based on long-term trends, very long-term. The ability to
identify and predict long-term economic, demographic, technological or consumer trends can benefit patient
investors who pick the right industry groups or companies.
Value Spotting
Sound fundamental analysis will help identify companies that represent a good value. Some of the most legendary
investors think long-term and value. Graham and Dodd, Warren Buffett and John Neff are seen as the champions of
value investing. Fundamental analysis can help uncover companies with valuable assets, a strong balance sheet,
stable earnings, and staying power.
Business Acumen
One of the most obvious, but less tangible, rewards of fundamental analysis is the development of a thorough
understanding of the business. After such painstaking research and analysis, an investor will be familiar with
the key revenue and profit drivers behind a company. Earnings and earnings expectations can be potent drivers
of equity prices. Even some technicians will agree to that. A good understanding can help investors avoid
companies that are prone to shortfalls and identify those that continue to deliver. In addition to understanding
the business, fundamental analysis allows investors to develop an understanding of the key value drivers and
companies within an industry. A stock's price is heavily influenced by its industry group. By studying these
groups, investors can better position themselves to identify opportunities that are high-risk (tech), low-risk
(utilities), growth oriented (computer), value driven (oil), non-cyclical (consumer staples), cyclical
(transportation) or income-oriented (high yield).
Knowing Who's Who
Stocks move as a group. By understanding a company's business, investors can better position themselves to categorize
stocks within their relevant industry group. Business can change rapidly and with it the revenue mix of a company.
This happened to many of the pure Internet retailers, which were not really Internet companies, but plain
retailers. Knowing a company's business and being able to place it in a group can make a huge difference in
relative valuations.
Weaknesses of Fundamental Analysis
Time Constraints
Fundamental analysis may offer excellent insights, but it can be extraordinarily time-consuming. Time-consuming models
often produce valuations that are contradictory to the current price prevailing on Wall Street. When this happens,
the analyst basically claims that the whole street has got it wrong. This is not to say that there are not
misunderstood companies out there, but it is quite brash to imply that the market price, and hence Wall Street,
is wrong.
Industry/Company Specific
Valuation techniques vary depending on the industry group and specifics of each company. For this reason, a different
technique and model is required for different industries and different companies. This can get quite
time-consuming, which can limit the amount of research that can be performed. A subscription-based model may work
great for an Internet Service Provider (ISP), but is not likely to be the best model to value an oil company.
Subjectivity
Fair value is based on assumptions. Any changes to growth or multiplier assumptions can greatly alter the ultimate valuation.
Fundamental analysts are generally aware of this and use sensitivity analysis to present a base-case valuation,
a best-case valuation and a worst-case valuation. However, even on a worst-case valuation, most models are almost
always bullish, the only question is how much so. The chart below shows how stubbornly bullish many fundamental
analysts can be.
Analyst Bias
The majority of the information that goes into the analysis comes from the company itself. Companies employ investor relations managers
specifically to handle the analyst community and release information. As Mark Twain said, "there are lies, damn
lies, and statistics." When it comes to massaging the data or spinning the announcement, CFOs and investor
relations managers are professionals. Only buy-side analysts tend to venture past the company statistics.
Buy-side analysts work for mutual funds and money managers. They read the reports written by the sell-side
analysts who work for the big brokers (CIBC, Merrill Lynch, Robertson Stephens, CS First Boston, Paine Weber,
DLJ to name a few). These brokers are also involved in underwriting and investment banking for the companies.
Even though there are restrictions in place to prevent a conflict of interest, brokers have an ongoing
relationship with the company under analysis. When reading these reports, it is important to take into
consideration any biases a sell-side analyst may have. The buy-side analyst, on the other hand, is analyzing
the company purely from an investment standpoint for a portfolio manager. If there is a relationship with the
company, it is usually on different terms. In some cases this may be as a large shareholder.
Definition of Fair Value
When market valuations extend beyond historical norms, there is pressure to adjust growth and
multiplier assumptions to compensate. If Wall Street values a stock at 50 times earnings and the
current assumption is 30 times, the analyst would be pressured to revise this assumption higher.
There is an old Wall Street adage: the value of any asset (stock) is only what someone is willing
to pay for it (current price). Just as stock prices fluctuate, so too do growth and multiplier
assumptions. Are we to believe Wall Street and the stock price or the analyst and market assumptions?
Conclusions
Fundamental analysis can be valuable, but it should be approached with caution. If you are reading
research written by a sell-side analyst, it is important to be familiar with the analyst behind the
report. We all have personal biases, and every analyst has some sort of bias. There is nothing wrong
with this, and the research can still be of great value. Learn what the ratings mean and the track
record of an analyst before jumping off the deep end. Corporate statements and press releases offer
good information, but they should be read with a healthy degree of skepticism to separate the facts
from the spin. Press releases don't happen by accident; they are an important PR tool for companies.
Investors should become skilled readers to weed out the important information and ignore the hype.